# Amazon Rings of Power series fan criticism

> Developing situation record from CLSTR: https://clstr.news/situations/amazon-rings-of-power-series-fan-criticism
> Updated: 2026-11-18T04:00:00.000Z. Sources: 11. Developments: 3.

Showrunners Patrick McKay and JD Payne have addressed ongoing criticism from audiences regarding the Amazon Prime Video series, The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power. While the production has received positive reviews from critics, audience scores on platforms such as Rotten Tomatoes have been lower, reflecting dissatisfaction among fans concerning creative deviations from the original source material.

In interviews with outlets including SFX Magazine and GamesRadar, the creators stated they are listening to viewer feedback and intend to learn from what works and what does not in the production. McKay clarified that while ignoring viewer opinions would be a failure in their roles, the audience does not unilaterally dictate the direction of the story. He emphasized that the producers must maintain creative control and consider themselves their own harshest critics as they evaluate future seasons. Following the release of the third season, McKay noted that the production team aims to apply these lessons as the story enters the War of the Ring.

## Timeline

### 2026-11-18: The Lord of the Rings creators and actors discuss production challenges

Showrunner Patrick McKay responds to criticism of ‘The Rings of Power’, while Andy Serkis recalls early tensions on the original film sets.

2 sources. https://clstr.news/cluster/the-lord-of-the-rings-creators-and-actors-discuss-production-challenges

### 2026-11-09: Amazon showrunners respond to Lord of the Rings fan criticism

Amazon showrunners Patrick McKay and J. D. Payne stated they are listening to fan criticism of ‘The Rings of Power’ but maintained that viewers will not dictate the creative direction of the series.

7 sources. https://clstr.news/cluster/amazon-showrunners-respond-to-lord-of-the-rings-fan-criticism

### 2026-11-04: Amazon creators address Lord of the Rings series criticism

Amazon showrunners Patrick McKay and JD Payne addressed fan criticism of The Rings of Power, stating they are learning from feedback as the series continues.

2 sources. https://clstr.news/cluster/amazon-creators-address-lord-of-the-rings-series-criticism

---
Cite as: Amazon Rings of Power series fan criticism. CLSTR, https://clstr.news/situations/amazon-rings-of-power-series-fan-criticism
