# Brazilian Supreme Court judicial and labor rulings

> Developing situation record from CLSTR: https://clstr.news/situations/brazilian-supreme-court-judicial-and-labor-rulings
> Updated: 2026-11-13T14:01:56.000Z. Sources: 47. Developments: 2.

Supreme Federal Court Minister Gilmar Mendes has issued several rulings and statements regarding labor rights and judicial authority in Brazil. In October, Mendes overturned a Regional Labor Court decision that had invalidated a collective clause concerning Sunday rest days for female hotel workers, ruling that the decision contradicted legal precedents regarding the autonomy of collective negotiations. In November, Mendes addressed judicial reform, questioning proposals to remove criminal jurisdiction from the Supreme Federal Court and citing the Lava Jato operation as a potential risk. He also maintained that the Labor Court should retain competence to judge cases involving “pejotização” to determine if such arrangements mask formal employment relationships.

In November 2026, debates regarding judicial reform intensified as Justice Edson Fachin called for profound reform to combat privileges, while Mendes urged caution. Mendes also engaged in a dispute with Senator Sergio Moro regarding the Guarujá triplex case. Following a court decision to return approximately R$ 2.4 million to the construction company OAS, Mendes accused Moro and former prosecutor Deltan Dallagnol of manipulating the justice system to remove President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva from the 2018 election. 

Mendes rejected Moro’s claim that Lula’s annulled convictions were based on “formal or political reasons,” instead alleging, based on evidence from Operation Spoofing, that Moro coordinated procedural acts, anticipated decisions, and interfered in the selection of interrogators. He further criticized the use of coercive measures, the interception of defense lawyers' communications, and the illegal disclosure of telephone conversations during the Lava Jato operation. Moro, a former judge in the Lava Jato operation, stated he would not comment on the remarks. Mendes characterized the entire operation as a “fraud” that shames the Brazilian judiciary.

## Claims

- Gilmar Mendes accused Sergio Moro of manipulating the justice system to exclude Lula from the 2018 election. (reported by 24 sources)
- Mendes alleged Moro acted in collusion with Deltan Dallagnol. (reported by 22 sources)
- The court authorized the return of R$ 2.4 million to the company OAS. (reported by 21 sources)
- Mendes described the triplex case as a fraud that shames the Brazilian judiciary. (reported by 13 sources)
- Mendes cited Operation Spoofing messages as evidence of procedural coordination. (reported by 12 sources)
- Moro stated that Lula's convictions were annulled for formal and political reasons. (reported by 8 sources)
- Mendes characterized Operation Lava Jato as a major scandal in the judiciary. (reported by 5 sources)
- Mendes urged caution regarding judicial reform proposals in Congress. (reported by 3 sources)

## Timeline

### 2026-11-13: Gilmar Mendes accuses Sergio Moro of manipulating justice system

Supreme Court Justice Gilmar Mendes accused Sergio Moro of manipulating the justice system to exclude Lula from the 2018 election, citing evidence of collusion and procedural fraud.

47 sources. https://clstr.news/cluster/gilmar-mendes-advises-caution-on-judicial-reform-and-labor-law-disputes

### 2026-10-16: Gilmar Mendes overturns ruling on Sunday rest days for female hotel workers

Brazil's Supreme Federal Court Minister Gilmar Mendes overturned a ruling that had invalidated a collective agreement granting female hotel workers one Sunday off per month.

5 sources. https://clstr.news/cluster/gilmar-mendes-overturns-ruling-on-sunday-rest-days-for-female-hotel-workers

---
Cite as: Brazilian Supreme Court judicial and labor rulings. CLSTR, https://clstr.news/situations/brazilian-supreme-court-judicial-and-labor-rulings
