# Polish Constitutional Tribunal reform debate

> Developing situation record from CLSTR: https://clstr.news/situations/polish-constitutional-tribunal-reform-debate
> Updated: 2026-11-18T23:26:52.000Z. Sources: 16. Developments: 4.

The Polish People's Party (PSL) has introduced a proposal for a constitutional reset of the Constitutional Tribunal to resolve ongoing disputes. The plan involves adding Article 194a to the Constitution, which would allow the National Council of the Judiciary to move for the expiration of current judges' terms if the Tribunal is deemed permanently unable to perform its duties. Under this mechanism, the National Assembly would elect 15 new judges via a three-fifths majority vote, requiring presidential consent and consultation with various legal bodies.

Krzysztof Bosak, leader of Konfederacja, has criticized the proposal, warning that the mechanism is overly complicated and could serve as a tool for future political majorities to remove judges, potentially undermining legal continuity. To advance the initiative, PSL leader Władysław Kosiniak-Kamysz has sought support from opposition leaders, including Sławomir Mentzen of Konfederacja and Mateusz Morawiecki of Rozwój Plus.

Jarosław Kaczyński, leader of Law and Justice (PiS), has conditioned his party's acceptance of a Tribunal reset on the formation of a presidential technical government. He argued that current proposals do not guarantee an end to constitutional violations and suggested the judge selection mechanism grants the ruling coalition excessive control.

Negotiations have recently reached an impasse, according to Zbigniew Bogucki, Chief of the Presidential Chancellery. While participants reportedly agree on the necessity of a reset, they have failed to reach a consensus on methods for phasing out the current composition. A draft proposal from the Presidential Chancellery, which expands upon the PSL project, includes an eight-year cooling-off period for former political actors and new rules for selecting judges. Political reactions remain divided: Patryk Jaki of PiS warned that certain proposed voting majorities could grant Donald Tusk veto power, while representatives from the Civic Coalition and the Left are not participating in these discussions.

## Claims

- Negotiations regarding the Constitutional Tribunal have reached an impasse, according to Zbigniew Bogucki. (reported by 4 sources)
- Political groups have committed to sending new proposals next week. (reported by 4 sources)
- The draft project was based on a proposal from the PSL, supplemented by other political groups. (reported by 4 sources)
- Representatives of the Civic Coalition and the Left are not participating in the talks. (reported by 3 sources)
- Jarosław Kaczyński stated a reset would be acceptable only if a presidential technical government is formed. (reported by 2 sources)
- The proposed project includes an eight-year cooling-off period for people previously involved in political activity. (reported by 1 source)
- Patryk Jaki warned that a three-fifths majority for selecting judges could give Donald Tusk veto power. (reported by 1 source)
- Grzegorz Płaczek stated that the current legal and political dispute undermines citizen trust in state institutions. (reported by 1 source)

## Timeline

### 2026-11-18: Krzysztof Bosak addresses Constitutional Tribunal crisis and right-wing unity

Krzysztof Bosak describes the Polish Constitutional Tribunal as paralyzed by government action and rejects proposals for a unified right-wing electoral list for 2027.

2 sources. https://clstr.news/cluster/krzysztof-bosak-addresses-constitutional-tribunal-crisis-and-right-wing-unity

### 2026-11-18: Poland Constitutional Tribunal negotiations reach impasse

Negotiations to reform Poland's Constitutional Tribunal have stalled, according to Zbigniew Bogucki. While a joint draft exists, parties disagree on how to phase out current judges.

12 sources. https://clstr.news/cluster/jarosaw-kaczyski-demands-technical-government-for-constitutional-tribunal-reset

### 2026-11-16: Kosiniak-Kamysz seeks PiS support for constitutional reset proposal

Polish PSL leader Władysław Kosiniak-Kamysz is consulting with opposition parties, including PiS, to gain support for a constitutional reset aimed at reforming the Constitutional Tribunal.

4 sources. https://clstr.news/cluster/kosiniak-kamysz-seeks-pis-support-for-constitutional-reset-proposal

### 2026-11-08: Krzysztof Bosak criticizes PSL proposal to reset Constitutional Tribunal

Konfederacja leader Krzysztof Bosak warns that a PSL proposal to reset the Constitutional Tribunal could create a permanent political tool to terminate judges' terms.

6 sources. https://clstr.news/cluster/krzysztof-bosak-criticizes-psl-proposal-to-reset-constitutional-tribunal

---
Cite as: Polish Constitutional Tribunal reform debate. CLSTR, https://clstr.news/situations/polish-constitutional-tribunal-reform-debate
