# Research on canine guilty expressions

> Developing situation record from CLSTR: https://clstr.news/situations/research-on-canine-guilty-expressions
> Updated: 2026-10-29T12:30:00.000Z. Sources: 18. Developments: 2.

Recent studies suggest that the ‘guilty look’ observed in dogs is not an expression of remorse or a realization of wrongdoing, but rather a reaction to human reprimand. 

Research published in Science Direct and conducted by the National Library of Medicine observed domestic dogs in their homes, finding that facial expressions associated with guilt were more frequent when animals were being scolded for disobedience. This suggests the behavior is a response to the owner’s conduct rather than an internal sense of guilt, a phenomenon linked to anthropomorphism.

Further research led by Dr. Alexandra Horowitz at the Horowitz Canine Cognition Lab, a cognitive scientist at Barnard College, found that specific behaviors—including lowered posture, averted eyes, flattened ears, and lip licking—were not reliably linked to whether an offense had actually been committed. Instead, these actions were closely associated with the owner’s body language, tone of voice, or emotional state. The study suggests these behaviors likely serve as attempts to reduce social tension or indicate appeasement in response to perceived threats or unpredictable interactions, rather than reflecting secondary emotions like guilt or shame.

## Claims

- Dr. Alexandra Horowitz led a study titled ‘Disambiguating the guilty look: Salient prompts to a familiar dog behaviour’. (reported by 4 sources)
- The ‘guilty look’ in dogs is not reliably associated with whether a dog actually committed an offense. (reported by 4 sources)
- Canine guilty-looking behaviors are more closely associated with a guardian scolding the dog. (reported by 4 sources)
- Dogs display behaviors like lowered posture, averted eyes, flattened ears, and lip licking. (reported by 4 sources)

## Timeline

### 2026-10-29: Research challenges assumption of canine guilt

Research by Dr. Alexandra Horowitz suggests that the ‘guilty look’ in dogs is likely a response to human scolding and body language rather than an actual feeling of guilt for wrongdoing.

16 sources. https://clstr.news/cluster/research-challenges-assumption-of-guilt-in-canine-behavior

### 2026-10-27: Study suggests dog guilty looks are reactions to human reprimand

Research indicates that dogs' ‘guilty looks’ are likely reactions to human reprimand rather than true remorse, while experts warn that traditional punishment can increase canine stress and fear.

2 sources. https://clstr.news/cluster/study-suggests-dog-guilty-looks-are-reactions-to-human-reprimand

---
Cite as: Research on canine guilty expressions. CLSTR, https://clstr.news/situations/research-on-canine-guilty-expressions