# Swiss Federal Supreme Court judicial ethics crisis

> Developing situation record from CLSTR: https://clstr.news/situations/swiss-federal-supreme-court-judicial-ethics-crisis
> Updated: 2026-11-07T03:45:27.000Z. Sources: 5. Developments: 2.

The Swiss Federal Supreme Court is facing an institutional crisis following revelations of a romantic relationship between judges Yves Donzallaz and Beatrice van der Graaf. The court is deliberating whether the pair entered into a “permanent life partnership,” a status prohibited by law for federal judges due to potential compromises to judicial independence.

The situation has caused significant internal turmoil. There are reports of dissatisfaction with the crisis management of President François Chaix, leading to proposals against his re-confirmation. Additionally, Judge Florence Aubry Girardin reportedly boycotted a preparatory session, describing it as “senseless” and an attempt to maintain a “semblance of procedural guarantees.”

The controversy has highlighted a deep divide within the court regarding legal principles, specifically whether a prohibited relationship can trigger a revision of a case and how a “permanent life partnership” should be defined. The Court Commission, led by National Councilor Leo Müller, is currently reviewing the matter to prepare recommendations for Parliament regarding the renewal of the court's membership.

## Timeline

### 2026-11-07: Swiss Federal Court faces internal rift over judges' relationship ruling

A relationship between two Swiss Federal Court judges has sparked an internal crisis, with one judge boycotting proceedings to protest procedural irregularities.

3 sources. https://clstr.news/cluster/swiss-federal-court-faces-internal-rift-over-judges-relationship-ruling

### 2026-11-04: Swiss Federal Supreme Court faces crisis over judges' relationship

The Swiss Federal Supreme Court faces an institutional crisis as it deliberates on whether a relationship between judges Yves Donzallaz and Beatrice van der Graaf violates laws regarding judicial independence.

4 sources. https://clstr.news/cluster/swiss-federal-supreme-court-faces-crisis-over-judges-relationship

---
Cite as: Swiss Federal Supreme Court judicial ethics crisis. CLSTR, https://clstr.news/situations/swiss-federal-supreme-court-judicial-ethics-crisis
