# Tata Power and Kleros arbitration dispute

> Developing situation record from CLSTR: https://clstr.news/situations/tata-power-and-kleros-arbitration-dispute
> Updated: 2026-11-07T11:46:56.000Z. Sources: 2. Developments: 2.

A legal dispute has emerged between Tata Power and Kleros Capital Partners regarding a proposed coal mining project in Russia. A Singapore-seated arbitral tribunal ruled that Tata Power must pay Kleros approximately $490.32 million, plus interest and costs, based on an alleged loss of opportunity for Kleros to participate in the project.

The award has faced significant scrutiny due to a major internal divergence within the tribunal. While the majority assessed damages at nearly $490 million, the Indian arbitrator, Justice A. K. Ganguly, dissented, valuing the damages at approximately $13.5 million. Legal experts and former Supreme Court Justice Vineet Saran have questioned the valuation, noting that Kleros reportedly made no substantial investments or project executions. Justice Saran referred to Kleros as a ‘Letter Box Company’ and argued the compensation relied on assumptions of future profits.

Tata Power has appealed the decision to the Singapore Court of Appeal. The company has alleged apparent bias among the tribunal members, citing non-disclosures and connections to a third-party funder for Kleros. Despite the pending appeal, a Singapore court has authorized the seizure and sale of Tata Power’s shares in two Singaporean subsidiaries to satisfy the award.

## Timeline

### 2026-11-07: Tata Power appeals $490 million arbitration award in Singapore

Tata Power is appealing a $490 million arbitration award in Singapore involving an alleged lost opportunity in a Russian coal project, amid allegations of arbitrator bias.

2 sources. https://clstr.news/cluster/tata-power-appeals-490-million-arbitration-award-in-singapore

### 2026-10-18: Tata Power faces scrutiny over Rs 5,500-crore arbitration award

Former Supreme Court Justice Vineet Saran has questioned a $550 million arbitration award against Tata Power in favor of Kleros, citing concerns over profit assumptions and lack of actual project investment.

3 sources. https://clstr.news/cluster/tata-power-faces-scrutiny-over-rs-5500-crore-arbitration-award

---
Cite as: Tata Power and Kleros arbitration dispute. CLSTR, https://clstr.news/situations/tata-power-and-kleros-arbitration-dispute
