started · updated
HYBE defends NewJeans contracts following NYT report on minor protections
HYBE and its subsidiary ADOR have issued a formal rebuttal to a New York Times investigation alleging that the K-pop group NewJeans signed unfair contracts while members were minors aged 14 to 17. The report claimed the agreements omitted standard South Korean government protections for education, sleep, and mental health, and required members to repay cosmetic surgery costs.
HYBE maintains that all its labels utilize government-standard supplementary agreements for minors that cover personal rights, education, and rest. The company stated that the contracts were negotiated in good faith over three months with the involvement of the members, their parents, and legal representatives. Regarding cosmetic expenses, HYBE denied pressuring members into procedures and noted that the company covered costs during trainee periods.
The investigation also highlighted provisions allowing ADOR to use AI-generated versions of the members' voices and likenesses indefinitely after contract expiration, as well as strict behavioral restrictions. HYBE responded that AI usage requires individual consent and that the contract terms, including penalty calculations for early termination, align with industry standards and do not disadvantage the artists.
Entities
Ador · Danielle Marsh · HYBE · Min Hee-jin · NewJeans · NewJeans · The New York Times
Claims
What the coverage asserts, and how many sources carry each claim.
- [● 11 SOURCES] HYBE denied that they recommend cosmetic procedures against an individual's will. isplus.com · www.sportschosun.com · www.mnnofa.com · recreio.com.br · world-today-journal.com · +6 more
- [● 7 SOURCES] The contracts reportedly allow ADOR to use AI-generated versions of the members' voices and likenesses indefinitely after the contracts expire. isplus.com · www.sportschosun.com · world-today-journal.com · ekr.chosunonline.com · www.hani.co.kr · +2 more
- [● 14 SOURCES] HYBE stated that all its labels sign government-standard supplementary agreements for minors that include protections for personal rights, sleep, education, and rest. isplus.com · www.sportschosun.com · www.mnnofa.com · recreio.com.br · world-today-journal.com · +9 more
- [● 10 SOURCES] The New York Times reported that NewJeans' contracts omitted standard protections for minors regarding health, education, and rest. www.mnnofa.com · recreio.com.br · world-today-journal.com · ekr.chosunonline.com · www.hani.co.kr · +5 more
- [● 13 SOURCES] NewJeans members signed their contracts in 2022 when they were between 14 and 17 years old. isplus.com · www.sportschosun.com · www.mnnofa.com · recreio.com.br · world-today-journal.com · +8 more
- [● 9 SOURCES] An email obtained by the NYT showed that when a member's mother requested contract revisions, an ADOR executive suggested reconsidering the contract itself. isplus.com · www.mnnofa.com · recreio.com.br · world-today-journal.com · ekr.chosunonline.com · +4 more
- [● 13 SOURCES] The contracts reportedly included provisions requiring members to repay cosmetic surgery and skin care costs. isplus.com · www.sportschosun.com · www.mnnofa.com · recreio.com.br · world-today-journal.com · +8 more
- [● 6 SOURCES] HYBE argued that the penalty calculation method for early termination is consistent with industry standards and does not increase the actual amount. isplus.com · www.sportschosun.com · ekr.chosunonline.com · www.hani.co.kr · www.seoul.co.kr · +1 more