started · updated
Canada Bill C-22 faces tech industry and constitutional opposition
Tech giants including Apple, Google, and Meta are lobbying the Canadian government to amend Bill C-22, a proposed lawful access law designed to assist police and intelligence agencies in digital investigations. Apple has expressed concerns that the legislation could undermine its ability to provide privacy and security features, specifically warning that it might necessitate the creation of encryption backdoors.
The bill would allow authorities to require service providers to retain user metadata for up to six months and potentially order companies to build technical capabilities to intercept communications. While lawmakers have introduced safeguards—such as prohibiting the forced introduction of systemic vulnerabilities and limiting decryption orders to companies that hold the necessary keys—critics argue these measures are insufficient.
University of Ottawa law professor Michael Geist has also raised concerns before a Senate committee, stating that the metadata retention provision remains “constitutionally vulnerable with little evidence of its necessity.” Geist noted that while metadata does not include message content, it reveals sensitive details regarding who individuals contact, when, and from which devices. The Canadian government maintains the bill is necessary to combat modern crime and is consistent with the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
Entities
Apple · Canada · Google · Intelligence Commissioner · Meta · Michael Geist