API
< Back to all clusters
[POLITICS] · Brazil · 2 sources

started · updated

Brazil: Judicial experts discuss STJ relevance filter and reform

Legal authorities and professionals in Brazil are evaluating the impact of the relevance filter implemented by the Superior Tribunal de Justiça (STJ). During the launch of the 15th edition of the São Paulo Justice Yearbook, Luciana Bresciani, president of the Public Law section of the São Paulo Court of Justice, stated that the use of the STJ as a third instance had become dysfunctional due to the unmanageable volume of daily appeals.

Bresciani noted that the filter should help unify legal understandings, allowing special chambers to establish theses that then guide future appeals. Leonardo Sica, president of the São Paulo section of the Brazilian Bar Association (OAB-SP), also supported the mechanism, citing the necessity of managing the enormous volume of processes reaching the court.

Separately, debates regarding broader judicial reform continue. Journalist Fernão Lara Mesquita has argued that internal oversight mechanisms, such as corregedorias, are insufficient to address institutional crises. Mesquita suggests that true reform requires addressing the stability and life tenure of magistrates, proposing models similar to the Missouri Plan to increase accountability to the citizenry.

Entities

Leonardo Sica · Luciana Bresciani · Ordem dos Advogados do Brasil · Superior Tribunal de Justiça · Tribunal de Justiça de São Paulo