started · updated
Brazilian Federal Court suspends Senate iPhone procurement
A Federal Court in Brasília has suspended a bidding process by the Brazilian Senate intended to provide mobile telephony services and high-end smartphones to lawmakers and staff. The contract, estimated at approximately 6 million reais, included the provision of 95 iPhone 18 Pro devices under a loan agreement (comodato) and 330 intermediate Android smartphones.
Judge Arthur Pinheiro Chaves issued the injunction following a popular action filed by Federal Deputy Nikolas Ferreira. The court noted potential irregularities, including the lack of technical justification for requiring specific premium Apple models and the potential violation of principles regarding economic efficiency and the prohibition of luxury goods in public administration. The judge highlighted that the Senate's own bid included Android devices, which weakens the argument that the institution's systems depend exclusively on the iOS ecosystem.
Separately, the Public Prosecutor's Office at the Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) has requested a suspension of the contract, which had been won by the operator Claro with a bid of 4.95 million reais. The prosecutor questioned the long-term economic impact of the monthly payments, noting that the cumulative cost could approach the price of permanent ownership without the assets being incorporated into public property. The Senate has been ordered to comply with the suspension, facing a daily fine of 50,000 reais for non-compliance.
Entities
Apple · Arthur Pinheiro Chaves · Brazilian Senate · Claro · Claro S.A. · Davi Alcolumbre · Federal Court of Accounts · Lucas Rocha Furtado · Nikolas Ferreira