started · updated
Brazilian court overturns conviction over Navy comments on João Cândido
The Federal Regional Court of the 2nd Region (TRF-2) has unanimously overturned a conviction against the Brazilian Union regarding statements made by the Navy about João Cândido Felisberto, the leader of the 1910 Revolt of the Lash. The ruling annuls a R$ 200,000 fine for collective moral damages and removes restrictions on official institutional statements regarding the historical event.
The controversy originated in April 2024, when the Navy sent a letter to the Chamber of Deputies opposing the inclusion of João Cândido in the Book of Heroes and Heroines of the Homeland. In the document, the institution described the Revolt of the Lash as a “deplorable page of national history.” While the Federal Public Ministry argued the language constituted racial discrimination, the court's rapporteur, Judge Sergio Schwaitzer, ruled that the Navy has the right to express its position to Congress.
The judge stated that the Navy's criticisms focused on the manner in which the revolt occurred rather than the racial or social origins of the participants. The court also determined that prohibiting such statements would constitute an undue restriction on the institution's participation in legislative debates.
Entities
Brazilian Navy · Chamber of Deputies · Federal Public Ministry · Federal Regional Court of the 2nd Region · João Cândido Felisberto