started · updated
Brazilian courts discuss mechanisms for legal precedent and thesis review
Francisco Loureiro, president of the São Paulo Court of Justice (TJ-SP), has advocated for greater proactivity from second-instance courts in proposing the review or replacement of binding theses established by the Superior Court of Justice (STJ).
Speaking at a national judicial meeting, Loureiro noted that while the STJ is responsible for reviewing themes, lower courts should not hesitate to admit special appeals based on the distinction or overcoming of existing precedents. This approach is intended to address themes that may require more nuanced interpretation or that have become costly for origin courts to apply.
In a related legal context, the Incident of Assumption of Competence (IAC) serves as a mechanism for courts to rule on relevant legal questions with significant social repercussion, even when they do not occur in mass repetition. The IAC aims to prevent divergence and uniformize understanding within a court, creating binding decisions for judges and fractional bodies under the Brazilian Code of Civil Procedure.
Entities
Brazil · Francisco Loureiro · Superior Court of Justice · São Paulo Court of Justice