started · updated
STF Justices clash over social media posts regarding Nossa Senhora Aparecida
A legal dispute has escalated within Brazil's Supreme Federal Court (STF) regarding social media posts about the patron saint Nossa Senhora Aparecida. Justice Flávio Dino overturned a previous decision by TSE Justice André Mendonça that had ordered the removal of posts, including one by comedian Antonio Tabet, which Mendonça claimed spread false information regarding candidate Flávio Bolsonaro. Dino argued that the removal lacked sufficient evidence of illegality and warned of potential 'mass censorship' and impacts on religious freedom.
In response, the campaign of Flávio Bolsonaro appealed to Justice Luiz Fux. Fux suspended Dino's decision and ordered digital platforms—including X, Facebook, TikTok, and Google—to comply with the original TSE orders within 24 hours. Fux also raised procedural concerns regarding how the matter reached Dino's office. Justice Dino has since referred his decision to the STF plenary for a final collective judgment, a move that STF President Edson Fachin is expected to schedule.
Entities
André Mendonça · Antonio Tabet · Banco Master · Conselho Superior do Ministério Público Federal · Daniel Vorcaro · Flávio Bolsonaro · Flávio Dino · Gilmar Mendes · Luiz Fux · Paulo Gonet · Superior Council of the Federal Public Ministry · Supreme Federal Court
Claims
What the coverage asserts, and how many sources carry each claim.
- [● 8 SOURCES] Justice Gilmar Mendes stated that the council's decision confirms the integrity of Paulo Gonet. cbn.globo.com · www.em.com.br · www.institutoliberal.org.br
- [● 3 SOURCES] The decision to reject the investigation against Paulo Gonet was reached with a 5-4 vote. www.institutoliberal.org.br
- [● 6 SOURCES] Justice Gilmar Mendes criticized the decision by André Mendonça to remove Federal Police Director-General Andrei Rodrigues. cbn.globo.com
- [● 3 SOURCES] The council decided unanimously that Gonet will remain in charge of investigations involving Daniel Vorcaro and Banco Master. www.institutoliberal.org.br
- [● 6 SOURCES] The Superior Council of the Federal Public Ministry (CSMPF) rejected a request to investigate Prosecutor General Paulo Gonet for alleged prevarication. www.institutoliberal.org.br · cbn.globo.com
- [● 5 SOURCES] Supreme Court Justice Gilmar Mendes criticized the decision to lift secrecy on the Federal Police report involving Gonet. cbn.globo.com
- [● 16 SOURCES] TSE Justice André Mendonça had previously ordered the removal of social media posts and imposed a R$ 30,000 daily fine. www.araucarianoar.com.br · imprensapublica.com.br · ojornal.net · www.portalcorreiodoagreste.com.br · www.leiaja.com · +3 more
- [● 2 SOURCES] The council voted 9-0 to allow Paulo Gonet to remain in charge of investigations involving Banco Master. www.institutoliberal.org.br
- [● 15 SOURCES] Flávio Bolsonaro's campaign alleged that the posts contained false information and hate speech. www.araucarianoar.com.br · imprensapublica.com.br · ojornal.net · www.leiaja.com · www.portalcorreiodoagreste.com.br · +3 more
- [● 16 SOURCES] Supreme Court Justice Flávio Dino overturned a TSE order to restore social media posts regarding Nossa Senhora Aparecida. www.araucarianoar.com.br · imprensapublica.com.br · ojornal.net · www.portalcorreiodoagreste.com.br · www.leiaja.com · +3 more
- [● 11 SOURCES] Justice Flávio Dino overturned a TSE order to restore social media posts regarding Nossa Senhora Aparecida. www.araucarianoar.com.br · imprensapublica.com.br · ojornal.net · www.portalcorreiodoagreste.com.br · canal38.com.br · +1 more
- [● 12 SOURCES] TSE Justice André Mendonça ordered the removal of social media posts and imposed a R$ 30,000 daily fine. www.araucarianoar.com.br · ojornal.net · www.portalcorreiodoagreste.com.br · canal38.com.br · ubajaranoticias.com.br · +1 more