started · updated
Supreme Federal Court faces crisis over Moraes and Mendonça investigations FAST-MOVING
The Brazilian Supreme Federal Court (STF) is facing an institutional crisis following a highly contentious session marked by personal attacks and procedural disputes between ministers. The conflict centers on a request by Alexandre de Moraes to investigate André Mendonça for abuse of authority and other crimes, stemming from the Banco Master case and communications involving former banker Daniel Vorcaro.
During the session, the court reached a 4-3 split decision on a procedural motion, ultimately deciding to keep the investigations of Moraes and Mendonça separate. Minister Flávio Dino requested a stay (pedido de vista) on a technical issue regarding the Banco Master case, which has effectively suspended the proceedings. There is significant internal expectation that Dino may only return the case for judgment after the October elections to avoid judicial influence on political campaigns.
Some ministers are advocating for the removal of the investigation request against Mendonça from the upcoming September 23 agenda, arguing that the lack of a definition on whether the cases should be judged together makes proceeding with Mendonça's case unfeasible. Meanwhile, STF President Edson Fachin has faced criticism for his handling of the session, and there are concerns that the internal friction could lead to further obstruction of plenary works.
Entities
Alexandre de Moraes · André Mendonça · Edson Fachin · Flávio Dino · Supreme Federal Court · Supremo Tribunal Federal
Claims
What the coverage asserts, and how many sources carry each claim.
- [● 5 SOURCES] Minister Flávio Dino requested a view of the case, suspending the judgment on whether Moraes and Mendonça should be judged simultaneously. www.direitonews.com.br · contraponto.jor.br · oimparcial.com.br · paraonline.com.br · portalolm.com.br
- [● 2 SOURCES] The STF session was characterized by open verbal aggression and mutual accusations between different factions of the court. www.direitonews.com.br · contraponto.jor.br
- [● 3 SOURCES] The Prosecutor General's Office (PGR) claims André Mendonça investigated Alexandre de Moraes illegally by deepening the Master case investigation without plenary authorization. oimparcial.com.br · paraonline.com.br · portalolm.com.br
- [● 2 SOURCES] A motion to unify the analysis of cases involving Alexandre de Moraes and André Mendonça was rejected by a 4-3 vote. contraponto.jor.br · oimparcial.com.br
- [● 5 SOURCES] Minister Flávio Dino has up to 90 days to return the matter to the plenary for judgment. www.direitonews.com.br · contraponto.jor.br · oimparcial.com.br · paraonline.com.br · portalolm.com.br
- [○ 1 SOURCE] OAB-PR President Luiz Fernando Pereira described the STF session as the most disturbing in the court's 135-year history. contraponto.jor.br
- [● 2 SOURCES] Minister Alexandre de Moraes requested an investigation into André Mendonça for abuse of authority and administrative improbity. valor.globo.com
- [● 3 SOURCES] The Supreme Federal Court (STF) voted 4 to 3 to keep the investigations of Alexandre de Moraes and André Mendonça separate. valor.globo.com · www.tnh1.com.br
- [● 2 SOURCES] Minister Gilmar Mendes proposed joining the investigation regarding Moraes with the investigation regarding Mendonça. www.tnh1.com.br
- [○ 1 SOURCE] The STF did not reach a decision on the merits regarding whether to open an investigation against Alexandre de Moraes.
- [● 3 SOURCES] Minister Flávio Dino requested a view (suspension for further study) during the STF session. valor.globo.com · www.tnh1.com.br
- [○ 1 SOURCE] Minister José Guimarães stated that the postponement of the STF trial brings the political situation back to zero.