Caleb Williams' Playmaking Draws Criticism Over Completion Rate

Fox NFL analyst Mark Schlereth argued that Chicago Bears quarterback Caleb Williams, despite his athleticism and record‑setting passing yards, is not yet a good quarterback because he relies on improvisation and posts a low completion percentage (58.1%). Schlereth highlighted that Williams often makes big plays in late‑game situations but lacks consistent timing, rhythm and efficiency.

Williams himself acknowledged the need to improve his fundamentals, saying he is working to raise his completion rate to help the Bears win more consistently. The Bears coaching staff has also emphasized improving his timing, processing and accuracy, aiming to combine his playmaking ability with greater efficiency.

The discussion reflects broader scrutiny of Williams’ development as the former No. 1 overall pick adapts to the NFL.