started · updated
Celtic FC faces coaching efficiency decline despite domestic trophies
Celtic FC has experienced a significant drop in coaching efficiency according to the Global State of Football report, produced by PLAIER and the University of St Gallen. Despite securing the Scottish Premiership title and domestic cup success during Martin O’Neill’s first year back at the club, Celtic received the only F grade for coaching efficiency in the Scottish Premiership for the 2025/26 season.
The report compares team performance against squad quality. While Celtic held an A grade and the highest club index in the 2024/25 report, their coaching efficiency score fell to -1.16. This decline follows a period of managerial changes involving Brendan Rodgers, Martin O’Neill, and Wilfried Nancy.
Beyond coaching metrics, the club maintains strong financial standing, receiving an A for financial stability. However, pundits have raised concerns regarding the club’s recruitment strategies, specifically referencing the “Nancy experiment,” and noted that European performance remains a weakness despite domestic silverware.
Entities
Brendan Rodgers · Celtic FC · Martin O’Neill · University of St Gallen · Wilfried Nancy