started · updated
Chief Justice Cho Hee-dae defends nomination rights at National Assembly audit
During a National Assembly audit, Chief Justice Cho Hee-dae asserted that the President and the National Assembly cannot interfere in the nomination of Supreme Court justices, calling such interference unconstitutional. Cho argued that while the practice of prior consultation with the President has been a long-standing tradition, it lacks a formal constitutional basis and that the Chief Justice has the right to nominate without such coordination.
The hearing was marked by intense political friction. Cho refused to take the witness oath or provide testimony regarding the nomination process, citing the principle of the separation of powers. This led to accusations from the Democratic Party that the Chief Justice was avoiding accountability, with some members suggesting impeachment. Conversely, the People Power Party condemned the Democratic Party's refusal to allow Cho to leave the hearing as an act of legislative violence and an attempt to intimidate the judiciary.
Additionally, Cho addressed allegations regarding the court's response to the recent emergency martial law, stating the Supreme Court did not cooperate and actively resisted unconstitutional requests from the martial law command. He also denied personal involvement in controversies regarding judicial encouragement funds and business expenses, attributing those matters to separate administrative officials.
Entities
Cho Hee-dae · Democratic Party of Korea · National Assembly of South Korea · People Power Party · Supreme Court of Korea · Supreme Court of South Korea
Claims
What the coverage asserts, and how many sources carry each claim.
- [● 3 SOURCES] Chief Justice Cho Hee-dae stated that interference in the nomination process by the National Assembly or the President is unconstitutional. www.kyeonggi.com · www.hani.co.kr
- [● 3 SOURCES] Cho Hee-dae denied that the Supreme Court cooperated with the recent emergency martial law, stating he instructed officials not to provide personnel lists. www.kyeonggi.com · www.hani.co.kr
- [● 3 SOURCES] Cho Hee-dae asserted that the long-standing practice of consulting with the President before nominating justices has no constitutional basis. www.kyeonggi.com · www.hani.co.kr
- [● 2 SOURCES] Democratic Party members suggested that the Chief Justice's refusal to take the oath and provide testimony could be grounds for impeachment. www.hani.co.kr · www.seoul.co.kr
- [○ 1 SOURCE] The People Power Party criticized the Democratic Party's refusal to allow the Chief Justice to leave the hearing as an act of legislative violence and confinement. www.seoul.co.kr
- [● 2 SOURCES] Cho Hee-dae stated he has no involvement in the specific disbursement of judicial encouragement funds. www.hani.co.kr