API
< Back to all clusters
[TECHNOLOGY] · United States · 5 sources

started · updated

Coinkite CEO defends Coldcard security after $116M Bitcoin exploit

Coinkite CEO Rodolfo Novak, known as NVK, is defending the security review process of Coldcard hardware wallets following an exploit that resulted in the theft of approximately $116 million in Bitcoin. The theft, which affected over 5,200 addresses, was traced to a March 2021 build error. This error caused the seed-generation code to use a software-based random-number generator instead of the device’s hardware generator, reducing the effective randomness of some seeds to as little as 40 bits.

NVK stated that at least 15 external security reviews or research efforts had examined Coldcard hardware and firmware prior to the discovery of the defect. He argued that a new AI model was required to identify the flaw that human reviewers missed.

Bitcoin developer Luke Dashjr has disputed these claims, asserting that human reviewers could have identified the issues. Dashjr stated he had previously raised nine specific concerns regarding the random-number generator with Coinkite privately. Additionally, James O’Beirne reported flagging issues with the firmware's fixed starting values in May 2025. Coinkite maintains that the devices were not remotely accessed, but rather that attackers used offline methods to regenerate private keys from the weakened seeds.

Entities

Coinkite · Coldcard · Luke Dashjr · NVK · Rodolfo Novak · TRM Labs