started · updated
Court of Justice of the European Union rules against right to refuse smart meters
The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has ruled that consumers do not have a general right under European law to refuse the installation of smart meters in favor of conventional equipment. The decision, rendered on November 5, 2026, follows a dispute in Austria where a customer contested the replacement of an old meter by a network operator, citing privacy and safety concerns.
The Court determined that EU Directive 2019/944 does not require network operators to accommodate requests from individuals wishing to maintain traditional meters. While the directive encourages the deployment of smart metering systems to modernize electrical networks and help consumers monitor usage, it does not grant an unconditional right to keep outdated hardware.
Despite this ruling, the CJEU emphasized that the installation of smart meters must still comply with strict data protection and cybersecurity requirements. The decision clarifies that while the transition to smart technology is supported, consumer data privacy remains a mandatory legal obligation for operators.
Entities
Court of Justice of the European Union · Enedis · European Union · Netz Niederösterreich