API
< Back to all clusters
[BUSINESS] · South Korea · 3 sources

started · updated

Court rules against Korea Zinc in management rights dispute

A South Korean court has ruled in favor of the Youngpoong and MBK Partners alliance in a lawsuit seeking to cancel resolutions made during Korea Zinc’s annual general meeting. The Seoul Central District Court determined that Korea Zinc’s attempt to restrict the voting rights of Youngpoong, its largest shareholder, constituted an abuse of rights.

To defend its management, Korea Zinc had utilized a circular shareholding structure involving its subsidiary, Sunmetal Corporation, and its grandson company, Sunmetal Holdings, to acquire Youngpoong shares. The company then argued that under commercial law, Youngpoong’s 25.4% stake should have its voting rights restricted due to these cross-shareholding relationships. The court rejected this interpretation, stating that the purpose of cross-shareholding regulations is to prevent distorted governance, not to serve as a tool for management defense.

The court further noted that the actions taken to form this structure could be interpreted as a violation of directors' duty of loyalty and potentially the Fair Trade Act. While the court dismissed claims that Youngpoong and MBK Partners were attempting an illegal takeover, it ruled that the methods used by Korea Zinc to restrict voting rights were unlawful. Korea Zinc has announced its intention to appeal the decision immediately.

Entities

Korea Zinc · MBK Partners · Youngpoong