Dave Portnoy reviews New Jersey pizzerias, boosting local spots

Barstool Sports founder Dave Portnoy, known as “El Presidente,” made a surprise visit to Vincent's Pizza in Hamilton Township, New Jersey, on August 4. He sampled the shop’s Brooklyn‑style pizza and chatted with owner Michael Sciabbarrasi, who said the visit was a highlight for the family‑run pizzeria that has been operating since 1980.

Later, Portnoy stopped at Classico Tomato Pies on Princeton‑Hightstown Road in West Windsor Township. He praised the thin, traditional tomato pie, giving it an 8.1 rating and noting its “very thin, very good” crust. Both reviews were posted as part of Portnoy’s One‑Bite series, drawing attention to the local pizza scene in Mercer County.