started · updated
Digital identity in Italy: Comparing SPID and CIE options
Users in Italy seeking digital identity services face various choices between SPID (Public Digital Identity System) and CIE (Electronic Identity Card), each offering different recognition methods, costs, and security levels.
SPID providers vary in their identity verification processes, which can include in-person appointments, webcam sessions, or digital tools like the CIE or digital signatures. Security is categorized into three levels by AGID: Level 1 uses username and password, Level 2 adds temporary codes or app confirmations, and Level 3 requires advanced physical tools. Providers such as Aruba ID, InfoCert ID, Namirial ID, Poste ID, and Sielte ID support Level 3 access, while others like Intesa ID and TIM ID are limited to the first two levels.
Alternatively, the CIE can serve as an access method. For Level 1 and 2 security, users can access services using a username, password, and the CieID app or SMS codes without needing to physically scan the card's chip. Physical chip reading is specifically required for Level 3 access.
Entities
AgID · Aruba ID · Italy · Ministero dell’Interno · Poste ID
Claims
What the coverage asserts, and how many sources carry each claim.
- [● 2 SOURCES] AGID divides SPID security into three distinct levels. www.webnews.it · www.chiccheinformatiche.com
- [○ 1 SOURCE] Aruba ID, InfoCert ID, Namirial ID, Poste ID, and Sielte ID support Level 3 SPID access. www.chiccheinformatiche.com
- [○ 1 SOURCE] CIE Level 1 and 2 access can be performed without reading the card chip using the CieID app or SMS codes. veb.it
- [○ 1 SOURCE] Level 3 access with CIE requires reading the physical chip. veb.it
- [● 2 SOURCES] Level 1 SPID security allows access via username and password. www.webnews.it · www.chiccheinformatiche.com
- [○ 1 SOURCE] Intesa ID, Lepida ID, Register.it, TeamSystem ID, TIM ID, and Etna ID are limited to SPID levels 1 and 2. www.chiccheinformatiche.com