API
< Back to all clusters
[POLITICS] · United States · 6 sources

started · updated

Ninth Circuit reinstates First Amendment challenge to California workplace speech law

The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has revived a First Amendment challenge to California Senate Bill 399. The law restricts employers from forcing employees to attend meetings regarding political or religious matters under threat of adverse job consequences.

The lawsuit was brought by the California Policy Center, a nonprofit focused on public policy research, through the Liberty Justice Center and the California Justice Center. The center argues the law limits its ability to hold mandatory meetings on political issues central to its mission.

While the state previously argued the center was exempt due to the political nature of its work, the Ninth Circuit ruled that the challenge could return to district court. The court noted that the intended political discussions might fall outside existing exemptions for job-related communications. The panel determined the law is content-based, subjecting it to strict scrutiny, as it only applies when an employer engages in expressive activity during meetings.

Entities

California · California Chamber of Commerce · California Justice Center · California Policy Center · California Restaurant Association · Liberty Justice Center · Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals · Western Growers Association