API
< Back to all clusters
[BUSINESS] · Germany · 2 sources

started · updated

German court rules solar rental with purchase option is not a consumer loan

The Higher Regional Court of Stuttgart has ruled that renting a photovoltaic system with a one-euro purchase option at the end of the term does not constitute a consumer credit agreement.

A homeowner argued that because the cost of dismantling the system (approximately 2,500 euros net) made the one-euro purchase the only economically viable choice, the contract should be treated as an installment purchase. This classification would have triggered consumer protection laws, such as mandatory interest rate disclosure, which could have significantly reduced the monthly rental payments.

The court rejected this argument, stating that a mere purchase option does not meet the legal definition of a consumer loan under Section 506, Paragraph 2, Number 1 of the German Civil Code (BGB). Consequently, the specific protections and interest rate regulations applicable to consumer credit do not apply to these rental contracts.

Experts note that solar rental agreements typically run for approximately 20 years and present specific challenges during property sales, inheritance, or roof renovations. In such cases, the buyer or heir can only take over the contract with the consent of all parties involved.

Entities

Germany · Higher Regional Court of Stuttgart