started · updated
German courts broaden AI‑generated content as evidence, ChatGPT used in defense
Courts in several jurisdictions are increasingly treating digital communications and AI‑generated content as admissible evidence. A São Paulo court ordered platform X to delete AI‑generated false statements, and a Johannesburg high court issued an injunction against defamatory WhatsApp messages targeting mining company Harmony Gold. These rulings illustrate a growing legal focus on messenger data and automated posts in civil, criminal and contractual disputes.
In Germany, security guard David Hinz, charged with fraud for receiving excess unemployment benefits, defended himself by using ChatGPT to draft legal motions. The AI‑generated bias‑removal request was accepted, leading the court to dismiss the case. The episode highlights the emerging role of large‑language models in individual legal strategies and raises questions about future reliance on AI in the justice system.