started · updated
German Federal Court of Justice rules on legal insurance for vaccine damage claims
The German Federal Court of Justice (BGH) has overturned a previous ruling regarding legal insurance coverage for claims involving alleged COVID-19 vaccine damages. The case involves a man who received three vaccinations in 2021 and subsequently reported suffering from an autoimmune deficiency. He sought to claim damages from the vaccine manufacturer, but his legal insurance provider refused to cover the costs of out-of-court proceedings, arguing that there were insufficient prospects of success due to the positive benefit-risk ratio of the vaccine.
Lower courts, including the District Court of Kleve and the Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf, had previously sided with the insurer. However, the BGH ruled that courts should not dismiss such claims based solely on the vaccine's overall benefit-risk profile. The court stated that requirements for "sufficient prospects of success" should not be excessive, noting that coverage may be required if the plaintiff's position appears "at least defensible" and if evidence can be presented. The case has been referred back to Düsseldorf for a new hearing.
Entities
District Court of Kleve · Federal Court of Justice · Germany · Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf