Hawthorn and Collingwood recruitment philosophies compared

The recruitment histories of the Hawthorn and Collingwood football clubs highlight contrasting player philosophies and recruitment outcomes. In 2023, Hawthorn expressed interest in Fremantle forward Lachie Schultz, but Collingwood secured his signature following their premiership success.

This decision had ripple effects on player movement. Had Schultz joined Hawthorn, it is suggested that Jack Ginnivan might not have been traded from Collingwood to the Hawks. While Ginnivan has become a prominent figure for Hawthorn, his profile and social media presence differed from the more understated, team-oriented style of Schultz, who is described as a defensive-minded player and a ‘cog in the machine’ for the Magpies.