Insurance underwriting viewed as capital allocation
Nuno Matos argues that insurance underwriting should be evaluated as an economic exercise of capital allocation rather than just a technical actuarial function based on premiums and loss ratios.
While actuaries calculate a technical premium by estimating claim frequency, severity, expenses, and volatility, market realities often cause the final price to diverge from these models. This divergence is a strategic decision: underwriters may offer discounts to retain key clients or gain market share, or conversely, set higher prices to signal a lack of interest in certain risks.
Ultimately, the core question in underwriting is not merely determining the technical premium of a risk, but deciding whether the company wants to allocate capital to that risk at a specific price point.