started · updated
Inter-American Court condemns Argentina over removal of Supreme Court judge
The Inter-American Court of Human Rights has held Argentina responsible for human rights violations regarding the 2003 impeachment and removal of Supreme Court Justice Eduardo Moliné O’Connor. The tribunal ruled that the Senate's decision to remove him via impeachment during Néstor Kirchner's presidency was linked to the content of his judicial rulings, thereby violating judicial independence.
The court found that the removal process lacked sufficient legal grounds and that judicial instances failed to adequately review defense arguments. Additionally, the ruling noted that the revocation of Moliné O’Connor's life pension and the decade-long delay in resolving his legal claims for that benefit violated rights to judicial protection, property, work, and social security.
As part of the sentence, the court ordered Argentina to regularize the pension regime, publish the ruling, and pay compensation for material and non-material damages, including legal costs. Moliné O’Connor passed away in 2014 before the final notification of this sentence.
Entities
Argentina · Eduardo Moliné O’Connor · Inter-American Court of Human Rights · Néstor Kirchner · Senate of Argentina
Claims
What the coverage asserts, and how many sources carry each claim.
- [● 3 SOURCES] The Senate removed Moliné O’Connor through impeachment in 2003 during Néstor Kirchner's presidency. impactoinformativo.com.ar · www.centraldenoticiasmadariaga.com · radiotvsierras.com
- [● 2 SOURCES] The revocation of Moliné O’Connor's life pension affected his rights. impactoinformativo.com.ar · radiotvsierras.com
- [○ 1 SOURCE] The impeachment accusation was approved by the Impeachment Commission with 16 votes to 1 on July 31, 2003. www.centraldenoticiasmadariaga.com
- [● 3 SOURCES] The removal of Eduardo Moliné O’Connor from the Supreme Court was linked to the content of his judicial rulings. impactoinformativo.com.ar · www.centraldenoticiasmadariaga.com · radiotvsierras.com
- [● 3 SOURCES] The Inter-American Court of Human Rights declared Argentina responsible for human rights violations regarding Eduardo Moliné O’Connor. impactoinformativo.com.ar · www.centraldenoticiasmadariaga.com · radiotvsierras.com
- [● 2 SOURCES] The court ordered Argentina to pay indemnities for material and non-material damages. impactoinformativo.com.ar · radiotvsierras.com
- [● 2 SOURCES] The judicial process to claim the pension lasted more than ten years without justification. impactoinformativo.com.ar · radiotvsierras.com
- [○ 1 SOURCE] Eduardo Moliné O’Connor died on August 20, 2014. www.centraldenoticiasmadariaga.com