started · updated
Inter-American Court judges case against Brazil over denied gender-affirming surgery
The Inter-American Court of Human Rights (IACHR) has begun a two-session trial regarding a case brought by Brazilian trans woman Luiza Melinho against the Brazilian state. Melinho alleges that the state denied her the right to gender-affirming surgery through the Unified Health System (SUS).
The dispute dates back 25 years. Melinho began medical transition monitoring at the Unicamp Clinical Hospital in São Paulo in 1997. After four years of specialist consultations, the institution reportedly canceled her scheduled surgery and advised her to seek care elsewhere. Following unsuccessful legal attempts in Brazil, Melinho funded the procedure privately in 2005.
While Brazilian courts previously ruled in 2008 that the surgery was a mere expectation of a right rather than a legal obligation, the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights accepted the complaint in 2016. A 2021 merit report recognized that the Brazilian state failed to ensure access to the medical procedure. A final ruling from the IACHR is expected in 2027.
Entities
Brazil · Inter-American Court of Human Rights · Luiza Melinho · Organization of American States · Unified Health System