started · updated
Israel debates new security doctrine and strategic objectives
Following the October 7 attacks, Israeli security experts are highlighting a shift in the nation's strategic doctrine. Major General Tamir Hayman, executive director of the Institute for National Security Studies (INSS), suggests that a “new concept” of national security has emerged in practice, despite lacking formal theoretical definition or public debate within the Ministry of Defense. Hayman argues that previous pillars of the Israeli general staff—such as the belief that peace is achieved through negotiation and that war is an anomaly—are now obsolete, impacting the country's national identity.
Complementing this shift, Meir Ben-Shabbat, former head of the Israeli National Security Council and leader of the Misgav Institute, argues that military success alone is insufficient to end the conflict. In a study published by the Middle East Forum, Ben-Shabbat posits that Israel must achieve a “cognitive defeat” among Palestinians. He contends that the goal should be to instill a lasting conviction that Israel cannot be defeated by force, stating that “it is not despair, but hope, that feeds terrorism and violence.”
Entities
Institute for National Security Studies · Israel · Meir Ben-Shabbat · Misgav Institute · Tamir Hayman