started · updated
Judge Carmen Mullen faces disciplinary hearing over alleged abuse of power
South Carolina Circuit Judge Carmen Mullen is facing a disciplinary hearing before the Commission on Judicial Conduct regarding allegations of abusing her position during a 2017 incident. The charges stem from an encounter at the home of neighbor and former attorney Ernest Lotito on Hilton Head Island.
According to the Office of Disciplinary Counsel, Mullen allegedly attempted to create a pretext for law enforcement to arrest Lotito, who was experiencing a mental health crisis at the time. Court documents suggest Mullen indicated to officers that she could sign a warrant to facilitate an arrest that evening, an action that officials claim created an ‘appearance of impropriety’ and challenged the impartiality of the judiciary.
Mullen denies any wrongdoing. Her legal counsel maintains she was acting in good faith out of concern for Lotito’s welfare during a volatile situation. The hearing follows previous scrutiny regarding Mullen’s alleged connections to disbarred attorney Alex Murdaugh.
Entities
Alex Murdaugh · Carmen Mullen · Ernest Lotito · South Carolina Commission on Judicial Conduct · South Carolina Supreme Court