started · updated
Judge maintains ruling that Los Angeles federal prosecutor is serving unlawfully
A federal judge has refused to stay a ruling that found Bill Essayli, the top federal prosecutor in Los Angeles, is serving his position unlawfully. Senior U.S. District Judge J. Michael Seabright rejected a request from the Department of Justice to pause his October order, which found that Essayli is acting improperly as a “de facto” United States attorney.
The ruling, set to take effect next Monday, prevents Essayli from participating in or supervising two specific criminal prosecutions. The legal dispute stems from the appointment process: after reaching a statutory limit as interim U.S. attorney, Essayli was appointed as a “special attorney” and “first assistant U.S. attorney” by then-Attorney General Pam Bondi, an arrangement that bypassed the required U.S. Senate confirmation.
While the Department of Justice argued that the legal issue could potentially affect 5,000 cases in the Central District of California, Judge Seabright dismissed the claim as an unsupported assertion, noting the government failed to identify specific harm. The decision aligns with a recent 9th Circuit ruling that invalidated a similar appointment mechanism in Nevada. Legal analysts suggest the decision could trigger broader challenges to Essayli’s authority across numerous other federal cases.
Entities
Bill Essayli · Department of Justice · J. Michael Seabright · Los Angeles · Pam Bondi