API
< Back to all clusters
[POLITICS] · Kenya · 3 sources

started · updated

Kenya High Court questions regulator authority to award privacy compensation

A Kenyan High Court ruling has challenged the authority of the Office of the Data Protection Commissioner (ODPC) to assess and award monetary compensation for data privacy breaches. Justice Francis Andayi set aside a KSh 1.25 million award ordered against Nutrihealth Solutions Limited, a Nairobi healthcare provider, after a patient discovered a CCTV camera in an examination room.

The judge ruled that while Section 65 of the Data Protection Act provides a right to compensation, the Act does not expressly grant the Commissioner the power to determine if damage occurred or to calculate the amount. The court noted that the power to order such payments currently rests in a 2021 regulation rather than the statute itself, meaning the regulation's validity may require a formal judicial review involving the Attorney General.

Additionally, the court questioned the procedural fairness of the ODPC's process, stating the regulator investigated, prosecuted, and issued a monetary determination without a full hearing, which potentially breached principles of natural justice. While the order for the clinic to remove the camera remains in force, the decision creates a legal precedent that could allow businesses to contest previous and future compensation orders issued by the regulator.

Entities

Francis Andayi · Kenya · Kenya High Court · Nutrihealth Solutions Limited · Office of the Data Protection Commissioner