[CLSTR]
< Back to all clusters
[CRIME] · United States · 30 sources

started · updated

Part of situation: Legal proceedings and mental health debates in Lindsay Clacy (43 clusters)

Lindsay Clancy trial ends in mistrial after 11-1 jury deadlock

Lindsay Clancy trial mistrial juror harassment double jeopardy postpartum psychosis

The murder trial of Lindsay Clancy, accused of strangling her three children in January 2023, ended in a mistrial after a 11-1 deadlock. While 11 jurors favored a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity due to postpartum psychosis, a single male holdout juror refused to agree, leading Judge William Sullivan to declare a mistrial on September 4.

Following the verdict, Judge Sullivan ordered the indefinite impoundment of all juror identities, citing a “real and present” risk of personal harm and harassment. This decision follows reports of social media doxxing and an individual being arrested for secretly recording jurors. The brother of the holdout juror has defended his sibling’s decision, stating that the vote was based on courtroom evidence rather than religious convictions, and noted that their family has been unable to leave their home due to relentless harassment.

In the aftermath, some jurors have spoken publicly. Paula Devlin stated the jury viewed the case as a “turning point” that could improve outcomes for women. Meanwhile, Clancy’s defense team has added attorney Martin Weinberg to pursue a motion to dismiss the case on double-jeopardy grounds. The case remains highly polarizing, drawing intense public scrutiny and commentary from political figures.

Entities

CBS Mornings · Donald Trump · Gayle King · Lindsay Clancy · Martin Weinberg · Nancy Mace · Paula Devlin · Plymouth County Superior Court · William Sullivan

Claims

What the coverage asserts, and how many sources carry each claim.

Sources

And, There It Is… Lindsey Clancy Holdout Juror Says He Feels Like He’s Being Targeted Because “He Is a Black Republican” – And the Juror Panel Was Democrats * The Gateway Pundit * by Jim Hoft [www.thegatewaypundit.com]
Juror's Brother Reveals Why He Chose Guilty in Lindsay Clancy Trial and Refused to Agree With Others [pulptastic.com]
Judge Seals Juror Names Indefinitely After Clancy Trial Harassment Campaign [americanfaith.com]
Judge In Lindsay Clancy Trial Orders Jurors’ Identities To Be Sealed Indefinitely [nemosnewsnetwork.com]
NBC vs. the Holdout Juror: Desperate for ratings, an NBC-owned TV station crusades against a hero [afnn.us]
Clancy Juror Says Mostly Female Jury Wanted to Leave Its Mark for Other Women [thepatriotchronicles.com]
Lindsay Clancy hires Karen Read attorney for high-stakes double jeopardy fight after murder mistrial [offthepress.com]
Nancy Mace Calls for Public Execution of Lindsay Clancy After Mistrial [www.planet-today.com]
VIDEO: Shocking Fallout: Juror's Family in Hiding After Lindsay Clancy Trial [internewscast.com]
In Praise of the Lone Holdout - The Panolian [panolian.com]
Brother of Lindsay Clancy Holdout Juror Speaks Out After Mistrial [wltreport.com]
‘So Very Christian of Her’: South Carolina Dunks on Rep. Nancy Mace Calls After Calling For Lindsay Clancy’s Public Execution [thenerdstash.com]
Watch: Lone Clancy juror breaks his silence, says he's being targeted for being a Black conservative [www.louderwithcrowder.com]
Gary Anderson: Top judge explains decision to free murderer from prison [www.bbc.co.uk]
Juror's brother in Lindsay Clancy trial reveals why he chose guilty and wouldn't agree with other jurors [www.unilad.com]
NCFM President Harry Crouch, When Ideology and Racial Hostility Enter the Jury Box: The Lindsay Clancy Verdict, Constitutional Crisis, and Male Disposability - National Coalition For Men (NCFM) [ncfm.org]
Brother of Lindsay Clancy Holdout Juror Speaks Out After Mistrial – 100PercentFedUp. com – by Jack [100percentfedup.com]
‘Must Be Stopped’: Megyn Slams Corporate Media-Led Smear Campaign Against Black Lindsay Clancy Holdout Juror [www.megynkelly.com]
Who is Paula Devlin? Lindsay Clancy juror under fire over 'turning point' comment, ‘Saying the quiet part out loud’ [articles.thelocalreport.in]
And, There It Is… Lindsey Clancy Holdout Juror Says He Feels Like He’s Being Targeted Because “He Is a Black Republican” – And the Juror Panel Was Democrats [freerepublic.com]
Nancy Mace Recommends What Many Are Too Polite to Suggest for Lindsay Clancy [pjmedia.com]
Wait, the Lindsay Clancy Juror Is a Catholic Haitian Immigrant? [townhall.com]
WBUR's Deb Becker on what it was like inside the Lindsay Clancy trial courtroom [www.wbur.org]
A Lone Juror Hijacked Deliberations. This Time, a Man Faces Execution. [theintercept.com]
Nancy Mace calls for public execution of Lindsay Clancy [www.rt.com]
Lindsay Clancy Holdout Juror’s Brother Reveals Why He Found Her Guilty: ‘He Made the Call’ [www.usmagazine.com]
Judge in Lindsay Clancy case impounds jurors’ names indefinitely, says at least one has gotten threats [www.boston.com]
Juror Says Lindsay Clancy Panel Saw Trial as Way to Support Other Women, Attorney Calls It Problematic [okmagazine.com]
US representative Nancy Mace says Lindsay Clancy should be ‘publicly executed’ after mistrial [www.ladbible.com]
Lindsay Clancy juror names indefinitely sealed by judge: ‘Real and present risk’ [nypost.com]