[CRIME] · United States · 89 sources

started 3 days ago · updated 1 day ago

Part of situation: Mistrial declared in Lindsay Clancy murder trial (29 clusters)

Lindsay Clancy murder trial ends in mistrial after jury deadlock

Lindsay Clancy mistrial postpartum psychosis jury deadlock Duxbury

The murder trial of Lindsay Clancy, a former nurse accused of killing her three children in Duxbury, Massachusetts, has ended in a mistrial. After more than seven days of deliberation, the 12-person jury reached an 11-1 split, with the majority favoring an acquittal based on the grounds of insanity.

Jurors who spoke publicly described the deliberations as an emotional experience. They noted that the lone holdout juror admitted to having reasonable doubt regarding Clancy's criminal responsibility but refused to agree to a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity. Some jurors characterized the holdout as arrogant and unwilling to engage with the group's consensus. Additionally, jurors mentioned that medical professionals on the panel used their expertise to help interpret toxicology reports during the process.

Clancy's defense, led by attorney Kevin Reddington, argues that she was suffering from postpartum psychosis at the time of the 2023 killings. Reddington has filed a motion to dismiss the case, citing double jeopardy grounds and arguing that a second trial is unnecessary. The prosecution maintains that Clancy acted deliberately. The case remains unresolved as authorities determine whether to seek a new trial or pursue a different legal path.

Entities

Donald Trump · Duxbury · Kevin Reddington · Lindsay Clancy · NBC10 · Patrick Clancy · Plymouth County Superior Court · Plymouth, Massachusetts · Roni Carlson · Ronni Carlson · South Shore Hospital · William Sullivan

Claims

What the coverage asserts, and how many sources carry each claim.

[● 22 SOURCES] The jury foreperson stated a lone juror admitted to having reasonable doubt but refused to vote for an acquittal. edmonton.citynews.ca · kitchener.citynews.ca · vancouver.citynews.ca · calgary.citynews.ca · halifax.citynews.ca · +13 more
[● 31 SOURCES] A judge declared a mistrial in the Lindsay Clancy case after jurors failed to reach a unanimous verdict. edmonton.citynews.ca · kitchener.citynews.ca · vancouver.citynews.ca · calgary.citynews.ca · halifax.citynews.ca · +22 more
[● 20 SOURCES] Prosecutors alleged Clancy acted deliberately when she killed her three children. edmonton.citynews.ca · kitchener.citynews.ca · vancouver.citynews.ca · calgary.citynews.ca · halifax.citynews.ca · +14 more
[● 26 SOURCES] Defense attorneys argued Lindsay Clancy suffered from postpartum psychosis during the killings. edmonton.citynews.ca · kitchener.citynews.ca · vancouver.citynews.ca · calgary.citynews.ca · halifax.citynews.ca · +19 more
[● 9 SOURCES] The trial took place in Plymouth, Massachusetts. www.castanet.net · www.newsday.com · www.ntd.com · www.lifezette.com · offthepress.com · +4 more
[● 20 SOURCES] The jury was nearly unanimous in favor of an acquittal based on insanity, but one juror refused to agree. www.e-radio.gr · www.madata.gr · articles.thelocalreport.in · www.index.hr · opserver.mk · +11 more
[● 4 SOURCES] Nurses on the jury used their medical knowledge to interpret toxicology reports during deliberations. www.breitbart.com · www.portadaestrela.com · articles.thelocalreport.in · theloftusparty.com
[● 7 SOURCES] Jurors described the holdout male juror as arrogant and unwilling to listen to others. www.e-radio.gr · articles.thelocalreport.in · www.breitbart.com · www.portadaestrela.com · www.tyla.com
[○ 1 SOURCE] Defense attorney Kevin Reddington plans to file a motion to dismiss the case based on double jeopardy grounds. offthepress.com

Sources

Lindsay Clancy’s lawyer asks the judge to spare her a second trial for killing her children [www.durangoherald.com]

1 day ago

«Ήμασταν ένα βήμα πριν την κηρύξουμε αθώα»: Τι αποκαλύπτουν τρεις ένορκοι στην υπόθεση Λίντσεϊ Κλάνσι [www.e-radio.gr]

3 days ago

WATCH: Exorcist priest slams women supporting Lindsay Clancy [www.lifesitenews.com]

1 day ago

Justice dies when sympathy replaces evidence [theclarion.ca]

2 days ago

Defensa de Lindsay Clancy pide que Trump la indulte tras anulación de su juicio [yucatanalamano.com]

3 days ago

Clancy Juror Admits Panel Had to 'Get Over' Mother Strangling Her Three Children [americanfaith.com]

1 day ago

What the Lindsay Clancy case tells us about our abortion culture [www.lifesitenews.com]

1 day ago

Lindsay Clancy's attorney says he's going to ask for case to be thrown out after hearing from jurors [offthepress.com]

3 days ago

(Видео) Мајка убила три деца во САД: 11 од 12 поротници ја прогласиле за невина [opserver.mk]

3 days ago

I giurati del processo a Lindsay Clancy si smascherano dopo l’annullamento del processo [www.portadaestrela.com]

3 days ago

Kevin Reddington speaks out against ‘horrific conspiracy allegations’ targeting Lindsay Clancy’s ex Patrick [pulptastic.com]

2 days ago

Caso Lindsay Clancy. Advogado pede que juiz a declare inocente após julgamento anulado - Renascença [rr.pt]

1 day ago

Lindsay Clancy case ends in mistrial, how would jury verdict play out in Alabama? (Video) [spotonalabama.com]

3 days ago

Clancy Attorney Trashes Online “Trolls” For “Evil” Comments About Admitted Child Killer Lindsay Clancy (VIDEO) * The Gateway Pundit * by Cristina Laila [www.thegatewaypundit.com]

2 days ago

Lindsay Clancy Jury reaction is mind blowing. [theloftusparty.com]

2 days ago

Clancy holdout juror mimicked strangling during deliberations, juror claims [thepulseofnh.com]

1 day ago

Lindsay Clancy Defense Seeks Acquittal After Mistrial, Argues Second Trial Is Unwarranted – [your]NEWS [yournews.com]

1 day ago

Lindsay Clancy's Attorney Denounces Patrick Clancy Conspiracy Theories [yve-style.com]

2 days ago

Matt Walsh NUKES Clancy juror 'wenches': ‘Every possible stereotype confirmed’ [americanwirenews.com]

1 day ago

Случај Линдзи Кленси: Зашто је 11 од 12 поротника рекло да није крива? [atvbl.rs]

3 days ago

After the Lindsay Clancy Verdict, Jurors Are Speaking Out — and Making Things Worse [christianresearchnetwork.org]

2 days ago

It's the Legal System That's Insane | CDN [conservativedailynews.com]

1 day ago

The ties between the Lindsay Clancy mistrial and a famous 290-year-old press-freedom case [dankennedy.net]

3 days ago

Holdout in Lindsay Clancy trial said he had reasonable doubt but still wouldn't acquit, juror says [edmonton.citynews.ca]

3 days ago

Lindsay Clancy Juror’s Unearthed Posts Show Support for Karen Read [internewscast.com]

2 days ago

Holdout in Lindsay Clancy trial said he had reasonable doubt but still wouldn't acquit, juror says [kitchener.citynews.ca]

3 days ago

The Lindsay Clancy Case Illustrates How ‘Decriminalizing [manhattan.institute]

1 day ago

Members of the Lindsay Clancy jury open up on the holdout juror [www.fox5atlanta.com]

3 days ago

Holdout in Lindsay Clancy trial said he had reasonable doubt but still wouldn't acquit, juror says [vancouver.citynews.ca]

3 days ago

JUST IN: Lindsay Clancy Juror Makes Shocking Admission: ‘I Thought She Was Guilty’ [trendingpoliticsnews.com]

2 days ago

Three jurors in Lindsay Clancy trial speak out following mistrial [www.tyla.com]

3 days ago

Murder: The Wake-Up Call [ulmhawkeyeonline.com]

2 days ago

Clancy holdout juror mimicked strangling during deliberations, juror claims - WEIS | Local & Area News, Sports, & Weather [weisradio.com]

1 day ago

Female Lindsay Clancy jurors criticized for 'trashing' lone male holdout who wouldn't acquit [www.christianpost.com]

2 days ago

Lindsay Clancy juror says holdout didn't show 'single piece of evidence' explaining vote [abc30.com]

1 day ago

Majka priznala da je ubila troje djece: 11 od 12 porotnika bilo za oslobađajuću presudu [bigportal.ba]

3 days ago

Lindsay Clancy’s attorney urges judge to acquit her to avoid a second trial [ca.news.yahoo.com]

1 day ago

Holdout in Lindsay Clancy trial said he had reasonable doubt but still wouldn't acquit, juror says [calgary.citynews.ca]

3 days ago

Holdout in Lindsay Clancy trial said he had reasonable doubt but still wouldn't acquit, juror says [halifax.citynews.ca]

3 days ago

Instapundit » Blog Archive » QUESTION ASKED AND ANSWERED: What Was the Holdout Juror Thinking? — Jill Filipovic, Slate, Sept [instapundit.com]

1 day ago

Mamas, Don't Let Your Daughters Grow Up to Be Wokesters [intellectualtakeout.org]

1 day ago

Lindsay Clancy’s attorney says he’s open to a plea deal, but there’s no easy path [krdo.com]

1 day ago

Frustrated Jurors Whine That Holdout Kept Focusing on What Lindsay Clancy Actually Did [WATCH] [www.lifezette.com]

3 days ago

Lindsay Clancy’s attorney says he’s open to a plea deal, but there’s no easy path [localnews8.com]

1 day ago

Watch: Kevin Reddington Tells Media Lindsay Clancy Was An “Amazing Mother” (She Murdered Her Three Children) [www.louderwithcrowder.com]

2 days ago

Δίκη Λίντσεϊ Κλάνσι: Αποκαλύψεις ενόρκων για την ομόφωνη απόφαση που δεν ήρθε [www.madata.gr]

3 days ago

(Видео) Мајка убила три деца во САД: 11 од 12 поротници ја прогласиле за невина [makfax.com.mk]

3 days ago

Lindsay Clancy Jurors Speak Out On “Very Arrogant” Male Who Prompted Mistrial [www.marieclaire.com.au]

2 days ago

Megyn Excoriates ‘Know-Nothing’ Lindsay Clancy Jurors Embarrassing Themselves While Trashing Lone Holdout [www.megynkelly.com]

2 days ago

Lindsay Clancy Jurors Reveal What Led to Mistrial [www.ntd.com]

3 days ago

Lindsay-Clancy-Geschworene: Einziger Verweigerer „gab zu, begründete Zweifel zu haben“ [www.rollingstone.de]

3 days ago

"Zoti President, shpëtojeni!"/ Avokati i Lindsay Clancy i bën kërkesën e papritur Trumpit [shekulli.com.al]

2 days ago

Don’t sympathise with Lindsay Clancy | The Spectator Australia [www.spectator.com.au]

2 days ago

Parties in Frisco murder case could have a resolution by next court hearing [www.summitdaily.com]

1 day ago

Lindsay Clancy’s Attorney Reveals Next Legal Move After 11-1 Jury Deadlock [theblast.com]

2 days ago

Lindsay Clancy verdict: Jurors break silence on tense jury room drama that led to mistrial verdict [articles.thelocalreport.in]

3 days ago

'12 People Too Dumb to Get Out of Jury Duty,' Lindsay Clancy Case Sparks Fury and Fear Over America’s Justice System [thenerdstash.com]

2 days ago

Majka ubila troje djece u SAD-u. 11 od 12 porotnika reklo da nije kriva - TIP. ba [tip.ba]

3 days ago

Fourth Lindsay Clancy Juror Breaks Silence With Damning Admission About Verdict Chaos [tvovermind.com]

2 days ago

Male Lindsay Clancy juror reveals what happened behind closed doors with holdout juror [www.unilad.com]

2 days ago

Jury selected for Jason Eaton trial, with opening arguments due Monday [vtdigger.org]

1 day ago

Kevin Reddington says Lindsay Clancy is ‘disappointed’ about mistrial, has ‘love’ for jury - Boston News, Weather, Sports | WHDH 7News [whdh.com]

2 days ago

Holdout in Lindsay Clancy trial said he had reasonable doubt but still wouldn't acquit, juror says [www.whec.com]

2 days ago

Lindsay Clancy's Lawyer to Seek Dismissal of Murder Case Following Mistrial [www.world-today-news.com]

2 days ago

Lindsay Clancy juror says holdout didn't show 'single piece of evidence' explaining vote [6abc.com]

1 day ago

Lindsay Clancy juror says holdout didn't show 'single piece of evidence' explaining vote [abc11.com]

1 day ago

Lindsay Clancy’s lawyer asks the judge to spare her a second trial for killing her children [abc13.com]

1 day ago

Lindsay Clancy’s lawyer asks the judge to spare her a second trial for killing her children [abc7chicago.com]

1 day ago

Lindsay Clancy’s lawyer asks the judge to spare her a second trial for killing her children [abc7news.com]

1 day ago

Lindsay Clancy juror says holdout didn't show 'single piece of evidence' explaining vote [abc7ny.com]

1 day ago

Lindsay Clancy Jurors Tell on Themselves After Mistrial [www.breitbart.com]

3 days ago

Holdout in Lindsay Clancy trial said he had reasonable doubt but still wouldn't acquit, juror says [www.castanet.net]

3 days ago

Lindsay Clancy’s attorney says he’s open to a plea deal, but there’s no easy path [cbs58.com]

1 day ago

Lone Lindsay Clancy jury holdout mimicked the horrific stranglings of killer mom’s three kids: ‘I was shocked’ [freerepublic.com]

1 day ago

Lindsay Clancy Jurors Brand Lone Male Holdout 'Arrogant' After He Admitted Doubt but Refused To Acquit Her [www.ibtimes.co.uk]

3 days ago

Poništeno suđenje majci koja je ubila troje djece u SAD-u. Porotnice otkrile zašto [www.index.hr]

3 days ago

Lindsay Clancy’s lawyer asks the judge to spare her a second trial for killing her children [kstp.com]

1 day ago

First male juror in Lindsay Clancy trial speaks out about ‘note’ sent to judge [www.ladbible.com]

2 days ago

Lindsay Clancy’s lawyer asks Trump for pardon after triple murder mistrial [metro.co.uk]

3 days ago

Holdout in Lindsay Clancy trial said he had reasonable doubt but still wouldn't acquit, juror says [www.newsday.com]

3 days ago

Jurados revelam tensão no julgamento de Clancy: "Era muito arrogante" [sapo.pt]

2 days ago

Jason Whitlock: The Lindsay Clancy jury chose her over the children | Blaze Media [www.theblaze.com]

1 day ago

Lindsay Clancy’s lawyer asks the judge to spare her a 2nd trial for killing her children [triblive.com]

1 day ago

Lindsay Clancy Asks Judge to Declare Her Not Guilty After Mistrial in Murder Case [www.usmagazine.com]

1 day ago

I experienced postpartum psychosis. But I got the right care, fast [www.wbur.org]

1 day ago

Lindsay Clancy’s lawyer asks the judge to spare her a second trial for killing her children [www.latimes.com]

1 day ago

‘We felt defeated’: Lindsay Clancy juror provides new details about the lone holdout [www.nbcnews.com]

1 day ago

Lindsay Clancy’s lawyer insists killer mom’s defense won’t inspire copycats despite eerily similar recent cases [nypost.com]

1 day ago

Lindsay Clancy’s lawyer asks judge to find her not guilty after mistrial [www.theguardian.com]

1 day ago