started · updated
Madhya Pradesh High Court rules Aadhaar cards are not conclusive proof of age
The Madhya Pradesh High Court has ruled that an Aadhaar card serves primarily as an identity document and cannot be treated as conclusive proof of a person’s age. The court observed that in cases where conflicting information exists, a postmortem report provides a more reliable basis for age determination due to the medical assessments conducted during examination.
The ruling came during an appeal filed by the parents of Harendra Singh Baghel, a 13-year-old boy who died in a road accident in December 2019. The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal had previously used the deceased’s Aadhaar card to determine his age as approximately 14 years, resulting in a compensation award of Rs 5.45 lakh.
Justice Amit Seth, presiding over the Gwalior bench, overturned this calculation by relying on the postmortem report, which recorded the boy’s age as 13. By applying the legal multiplier for a minor, the High Court enhanced the total compensation awarded to the parents to Rs 8.25 lakh.
Entities
Amit Seth · Gwalior · Harendra Singh Baghel · Madhya Pradesh High Court · Rajesh Singh