Marvel’s Wolverine receives mixed reviews with a Metacritic score of 77

Insomniac Games’ Marvel’s Wolverine has received mixed critical reviews ahead of its September 15 release on PlayStation 5. The title currently holds a Metacritic score of approximately 77–78, marking a notable departure from the studio’s previous high-scoring hits like Marvel’s Spider-Man 2, which earned a 90.

Critics have highlighted a significant shift in design, moving away from the open-world format of previous titles toward a more linear, narrative-driven experience. While the combat is praised for being visceral and brutal, some reviewers have noted that the gameplay can feel repetitive over time.

Controversy has also emerged regarding the game’s narrative direction. Insomniac’s narrative director, Walt Williams, sparked discussion by describing the rivalry between Wolverine and Sabretooth as having “room for love,” framing their intense conflict through a lens of emotional yearning. This character-focused approach, intended to provide a more somber and mature tone, has drawn varied reactions from the gaming community.