API
< Back to all clusters
[CRIME] · Brazil · 6 sources

started · updated

Mato Grosso Court validates cell phone data used to identify theft suspect

The Third Criminal Chamber of the Mato Grosso Court of Justice (TJMT) has ruled that information obtained from a mobile phone left at a crime scene is valid evidence for identifying suspects. The decision pertains to a qualified theft case in the Sinop region, where a perpetrator dropped their device during the commission of the crime.

The victim discovered the phone and accessed its contents to identify the suspect. While the defense argued that accessing the data without a judicial warrant violated privacy rights, the rapporteur, Judge Juanita Cruz da Silva Clait Duarte, cited a Supreme Federal Court (STF) precedent. This precedent allows access to data from devices found fortuitously at crime scenes if the sole purpose is to identify the owner or clarify authorship.

The court noted that the initial access was performed by the victim without the involvement or guidance of public officials. In addition to validating the evidence, the court reviewed the sentencing of the two convicted men, addressing arguments regarding the proportionality of penalties and the consideration of nighttime theft as an aggravating factor.

Entities

Juanita Cruz da Silva Clait Duarte · Mato Grosso Court of Justice · Sinop · Supreme Federal Court