started · updated
Mexico Supreme Court validates prison sentences for medical negligence
The Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation (SCJN) has ruled that medical negligence resulting in permanent injury to patients can carry criminal penalties of three to five years in prison. The decision confirms the constitutionality of articles 60 and 291 of the Federal Penal Code.
The ruling follows an amparo lawsuit filed by a neurosurgeon from the Mexican Social Security Institute (IMSS). The specialist was facing charges for involuntary injuries after a patient suffered permanent loss of mobility in a leg following spinal surgeries in 2017. While the defense argued that criminal prosecution is disproportionate and creates professional uncertainty, the Court determined that clinical protocols can be used to evaluate negligence.
The Court clarified that criminal liability does not stem from the ordinary risks of medical practice or unfavorable surgical outcomes, but rather from injuries attributable to culpable conduct and a failure to follow required professional procedures.
Entities
Federal General Prosecutor's Office · María Estela Ríos González · Mexican Social Security Institute · Mexico · Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation