started · updated
MI5 avoids contempt of court charges over false evidence
The High Court has ruled that MI5 and its Director General, Sir Ken McCallum, will not face contempt of court proceedings despite the agency admitting it provided false evidence to three courts. Senior judges, including Lady Chief Justice Baroness Sue Carr, determined that initiating such proceedings would not be in the public interest due to the complexity and resource-intensive nature of the case.
The false evidence concerned communications between MI5 and the BBC regarding an abusive informant known as Agent X. This misinformation was used in a 2022 successful bid for an injunction that prevented the BBC from airing a documentary about the agent. An investigation by Sir John Goldring concluded there were “serious and systemic failures in MI5’s conduct,” finding that one senior officer lied repeatedly while another misled colleagues.
While the agency and its leadership avoid corporate contempt charges, individual officers may still face investigation for misconduct in public office. One criticized officer has resigned, and another is undergoing internal disciplinary proceedings. Sir Ken McCallum stated that the judgment “underlines MI5’s serious failures in this case,” acknowledging that the agency “fell badly short.”
Entities
BBC · Baroness Sue Carr · High Court · MI5 · Sir Ken McCallum