started · updated
Michigan court strikes down election poll book deletion rule
The Michigan Court of Claims has struck down a rule established by Secretary of State Jocelyn Benson that required election clerks to delete electronic poll book software and associated files within seven days of an election's certification.
Judge Michael J. Riordan ruled that the administrative rule conflicted with Michigan state law, which requires election records to be retained for 22 months. The court found that the rule was invalid because, when an administrative rule conflicts with a statute, the statute controls. The ruling emphasized that retaining metadata is as crucial as retaining the data itself.
The decision applies statewide to all 1,520 clerks in Michigan and is effective immediately. The court has directed the Secretary of State to issue new instructions to clerks regarding the retention of poll book files on encrypted flash drives for the legally required 22-month period.
Entities
Jocelyn Benson · Michael J. Riordan · Michigan · Michigan Court of Claims