started · updated
Min Hee-jin wins legal battle against HYBE subsidiaries
A Seoul court has ruled in favor of former ADOR CEO Min Hee-jin in multiple defamation and damages lawsuits filed by HYBE subsidiaries Belift Lab and Source Music. The court rejected Belift Lab’s demand for 2 billion won in compensation, which was based on allegations that Min defamed the group ILLIT by claiming they copied the creative identity of NewJeans.
The Seoul Western District Court determined that Min’s remarks regarding the similarities between the two groups constituted subjective opinions and evaluations rather than false statements of fact. The ruling noted that in the field of popular culture, it is difficult to establish uniform criteria for imitation, and freedom of expression should be broadly protected regarding debates over originality.
Similarly, the court dismissed a 500 million won lawsuit from Source Music, finding that Min’s comments regarding the recruitment and debut process of NewJeans members were not definitively false or illegally insulting.
In a separate proceeding, the court also dismissed Min’s countersuit seeking 5 billion won in damages from Belift Lab. The court ruled that the economic success and reputation of NewJeans belong to the corporate entities involved rather than Min personally. Belift Lab and Source Music have both announced their intention to appeal the decision.
Entities
BELIFT LAB · HYBE · Min Hee-jin · NewJeans · SOURCE MUSIC