API
< Back to all clusters
[POLITICS] · Germany · 2 sources

started · updated

Münster court rules kidney stones are not a bar to police employment

The Higher Administrative Court of Münster has ruled that having kidney stones is not a valid reason to reject a candidate for police service. The court dismissed an appeal by the state of North Rhine-Westphalia, upholding a previous decision that favored a job applicant from the Heinsberg district.

The state had originally rejected the applicant, citing its duty of care. Officials argued they could not guarantee the necessary follow-up care or ensure the prevention of new stones during all types of police assignments, particularly where optimal nutrition and hydration might be difficult to maintain.

However, the court found that the state failed to demonstrate a specific health risk that would justify restricting the applicant's employment. The judges noted that medical guidelines for preventing kidney stones—such as maintaining high fluid intake and a balanced diet—could be managed, and the state did not convincingly prove that these measures could not be met during police duties.

Entities

Administrative Court of Aachen · Higher Administrative Court of Münster · North Rhine-Westphalia

Sources