started · updated
New York City Council passes bill banning surveillance pricing
The New York City Council has passed a bill to prohibit surveillance pricing, a practice where companies use personal data and algorithms to charge different prices to different customers for the same goods or services. Introduced by Council Speaker Julie Menin, the legislation targets the use of consumer behavior, location, and purchase history to determine individualized pricing.
The bill applies to both online and physical retail environments. It specifically prohibits using algorithms to set prices based on personal data, as well as advertising such prices or selling data collected for this purpose. The Council cited instances of price manipulation, such as a retailer increasing a television price once a customer entered a store parking lot, as justification for the measure.
Exceptions are permitted for certain legitimate business practices, including location-based services for delivery or ride-sharing, insurance regulations, and specific membership discounts. To qualify for discounts, businesses must disclose terms and apply them uniformly to all qualifying members.
The Department of Consumer and Worker Protection will oversee enforcement. Violations may result in civil penalties of up to $1,000 per transaction or individual customer. The bill now awaits the mayor's signature and will take effect one year after becoming law.
Entities
Department of Consumer and Worker Protection · Julie Menin · New York City · New York City Council