Ontario Court of Appeal rules no constitutional right to bike lanes

The Ontario Court of Appeal has ruled that there is no legal or constitutional right to bike lanes, a decision that has sparked political debate in Alberta. The unanimous ruling overturned a previous decision that had suggested removing bike lanes could violate cyclists' rights to life and security under the Charter.

In Alberta, Transportation Minister Devin Dreeshen welcomed the ruling, calling it a win for “common sense” and stating that the government will consider the findings as it finalizes legislation regarding transportation infrastructure. The Alberta government has previously expressed concerns regarding planned bike lanes on Edmonton’s 50 Street.

Edmonton Mayor Andrew Knack criticized the focus on bike lanes, arguing that the debate wastes time that should be spent addressing road fatalities and improving transit and roadway networks. Advocacy groups, such as Ward Métis Bikes, have also expressed concern that the issue is being used to build political support.