started · updated
Flávio Bolsonaro denies claims regarding Nossa Senhora Aparecida
A political controversy has erupted in Brazil involving presidential candidate Flávio Bolsonaro and the National Conference of Bishops of Brazil (CNBB). The dispute centers on false information circulating on social media claiming that Bolsonaro intends to strip Nossa Senhora Aparecida of her title as the patron saint of Brazil if elected.
Flávio Bolsonaro has denied these claims, labeling them as a disinformation campaign orchestrated by the Workers' Party (PT) with assistance from individuals within the CNBB. In response, the CNBB issued an official statement denying any involvement in the creation or dissemination of false information, emphasizing its independence from political parties and its commitment to its pastoral mission.
The controversy has reached the judiciary. The Superior Electoral Court (TSE) initially ordered the removal of certain social media posts related to the matter, but Supreme Court Minister Flávio Dino later overturned that decision, citing freedom of expression. Additionally, a request has been filed with the Federal Public Ministry (MPF) to investigate whether any actual legislative initiatives exist to change the legal status of the patron saint, referencing a rejected 2007 project.
Amidst the tension, Flávio Bolsonaro has made public gestures of religious devotion, including appearing with an image of the saint during campaign events, while other religious figures, such as Pastor J.B. Carvalho, have historically expressed critical views regarding the legal status of the patroness.
Entities
CNBB · Comunidade das Nações · Flávio Bolsonaro · Flávio Dino · JB Carvalho · Jorge Messias · Nossa Senhora Aparecida · Nossa Senhora Aparecida · Nossa Senhora Aparecida Basilica · PT · Supreme Court of Brazil · Supreme Federal Court
Claims
What the coverage asserts, and how many sources carry each claim.
- [● 23 SOURCES] Flávio Bolsonaro thanked the CNBB after it denied involvement in spreading rumors about the patroness. oaltoacre.com · www.cnbb.org.br · exame.com · contilnetnoticias.com.br · srzd.com · +11 more
- [● 4 SOURCES] Flávio Bolsonaro stated that if elected president, he would declare that Brazil belongs to the Lord Jesus Christ.
- [● 4 SOURCES] Pastor JB Carvalho claims that the devotion to the 'Queen of Heaven' is a pagan practice that God hates. srzd.com
- [● 23 SOURCES] The CNBB maintains it does not belong to any political party or candidacy structure. www.cnbb.org.br · contilnetnoticias.com.br · srzd.com · br.paipee.com · paraonline.com.br · +12 more
- [● 20 SOURCES] Flávio Bolsonaro denied the intention to remove the title of Patroness from Nossa Senhora Aparecida. br.paipee.com · imprensapublica.com.br · www.alagoas24horas.com.br · contilnetnoticias.com.br · agorarn.com.br · +10 more
- [● 22 SOURCES] Flávio Bolsonaro accused the PT party of orchestrating a campaign to spread rumors regarding the status of Nossa Senhora Aparecida with help from within the CNBB. oaltoacre.com · exame.com · www.dgabc.com.br · br.paipee.com · paraonline.com.br · +12 more
- [● 26 SOURCES] The CNBB denied involvement in spreading false information regarding the status of Nossa Senhora Aparecida. oaltoacre.com · exame.com · www.dgabc.com.br · br.paipee.com · jovempan.com.br · +13 more
- [● 11 SOURCES] Supreme Court Minister Flávio Dino overturned a decision to remove posts by comedian Antonio Tabet, citing freedom of expression. oaltoacre.com · exame.com · www.dgabc.com.br · imprensapublica.com.br · correiodobrasil.com.br · +1 more
- [● 5 SOURCES] A 2007 legislative project proposed changing the designation of Nossa Senhora Aparecida from 'Patroness of Brazil' to 'Patroness of Catholic Brazilians'. br.paipee.com · regionalzao.com.br · www.ouricuriemfoco.com.br
- [○ 1 SOURCE] A Secom official shared at least 10 posts containing disinformation regarding Flávio Bolsonaro. informatudodf.com.br
- [● 2 SOURCES] The CNBB does not belong to any political party or support any specific candidacy. portalcambe.com.br
- [○ 1 SOURCE] The claim that Flávio Bolsonaro intended to remove Nossa Senhora Aparecida as the patron saint of Brazil is a lie.