started · updated
Phil Gordon accuses Netanyahu of delaying hostage deal to protect government
Phil Gordon, a former national security adviser in the Biden administration, has accused Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of delaying a hostage-release deal with Hamas for six months in 2024. Gordon alleges that Netanyahu prioritized the political survival of his government over securing the release of captives and ending the war in Gaza.
According to Gordon, Hamas had accepted the basic framework of a U.S.-backed agreement in July 2024, including dropping the demand for a permanent ceasefire prior to hostage releases. However, Netanyahu reportedly introduced new conditions—such as maintaining Israeli military presence along the Gaza-Egypt border and implementing new inspection mechanisms in northern Gaza—which Gordon claims were contrary to the advice of Israeli security leaders.
Gordon argues that this delay contributed to the deaths of several Israeli hostages and approximately 9,000 Palestinians. He also challenged recent claims that Brett McGurk’s account of the administration's Middle East policy vindicates Netanyahu’s conduct, stating that many former officials believe the United States should have exerted more sustained pressure on Israel to conclude the conflict sooner.
Entities
Benjamin Netanyahu · Biden administration · Binyamin Netanyahu · Brett McGurk · Hamas · Joe Biden · Phil Gordon
Claims
What the coverage asserts, and how many sources carry each claim.
- [● 2 SOURCES] An estimated 9,000 additional Palestinians were killed during the six-month delay in negotiations. zmnfm.ps · palsawa.com
- [● 2 SOURCES] Most former Biden administration officials believe the U.S. should have applied more pressure on Israel to end the war sooner. matzav.com · tdpelmedia.com
- [● 3 SOURCES] Hamas accepted the basic framework of a proposed hostage agreement in July 2024. zmnfm.ps · matzav.com · tdpelmedia.com
- [● 2 SOURCES] The delay in reaching a hostage agreement lasted approximately six months. matzav.com · palsawa.com
- [● 2 SOURCES] Netanyahu's additional conditions included maintaining Israeli forces along the Gaza-Egypt border. zmnfm.ps · palsawa.com
- [● 2 SOURCES] Netanyahu's conditions included a new mechanism for inspecting Palestinians returning to homes in northern Gaza. zmnfm.ps · palsawa.com
- [● 2 SOURCES] Netanyahu introduced new conditions to the hostage proposal in July 2024, contrary to advice from Israeli security leaders. zmnfm.ps · matzav.com
- [● 4 SOURCES] Phil Gordon accused Benjamin Netanyahu of prioritizing his government's survival over a hostage deal and ending the war in Gaza. zmnfm.ps · matzav.com · palsawa.com · tdpelmedia.com