started · updated
Portugal judges' union disputes new productivity indicators
Judge‑secretary Eliana de Almeida Pinto of the Superior Council of Administrative and Fiscal Courts (CSTAF) denounced precautionary measures filed by the Portuguese Judges' Union (ASJP) as “unjustifiable precipitations”. The union challenged the new productivity indicators – the Values of Procedural Reference (VPR) – set by the Council in July, arguing they are not legally binding and clash with the global and contextual evaluation framework established by the Magistrates' Statute and Inspection Regulations.
Pinto countered that productivity is only one factor in judicial assessment and should not become a quantitative threshold that determines magistrates' classifications. She emphasized that past evaluations were based on individual inspector judgments rather than abstract, published thresholds, and called for greater transparency rather than rigid numeric standards.
Entities
Associação Sindical dos Juízes Portugueses · Conselho Superior dos Tribunais Administrativos e Fiscais · Eliana de Almeida Pinto