started · updated
Portugal Supreme Court denies Berardo compensation claim
The Portuguese Supreme Administrative Court (STA) has rejected an indemnification request from businessman José Berardo and the Associação Colecção Berardo. The claim was filed against the Presidency of the Council of Ministers following the 2022 decision by the government of António Costa to terminate the protocol with the association, which led to the extinction of the Fundação de Arte Moderna e Contemporânea – Colecção Berardo.
The court ruled the action unfounded, stating that the plaintiffs failed to demonstrate specific patrimonial or non-patrimonial damages or provide concrete values for compensation. The STA noted that the State ensures the maintenance of conditions existing prior to the seizure of assets, regarding both public access to the cultural collection and the exchange or loan of artworks.
The dispute stems from a 2019 legal action by Banco Comercial Português, Novo Banco, and Caixa Geral de Depósitos, seeking repayment of debts totaling approximately one billion euros. As a result, the art collection was seized and remains under state custody pending a final judicial decision on the primary debt litigation.
Entities
Associação Colecção Berardo · José Berardo · Portugal · Presidency of the Council of Ministers · Supreme Administrative Court